Official Site of the first ever successful Citizen's Initiative Victory followed by an HST Referendum Victory



Vander Zalm: BC Government’s so-called “Independent Panel on HST” report delayed to avoid becoming federal election issue, so Fight HST releasing its own study.

DELTA – (Tuesday, April 5, 2011) – Former BC premier and Fight HST Leader Bill Vander Zalm says his grassroots volunteer group has completed a comprehensive study on the problems with the Harmonized Sales Tax in BC, elsewhere in Canada and worldwide and is releasing its report today.

Vander Zalm says the BC government’s so-called “Independent Panel” was originally scheduled to publish its findings this week, but declined to do so to avoid the HST becoming a significant issue during the federal election.

“Why would a supposedly independent group’s report on the HST not be released as planned – unless the BC government was scared it would become a major issue during this federal election,” Vander Zalm said. “BC voters have consistently been left in the dark about the HST by the BC Liberal government since before the 2009 provincial election when they denied plans to impose it.  Now they’re doing it again.”

Vander Zalm says BC voters are preparing for the upcoming June 24 mail-in ballot referendum on extinguishing the HST and need solid information to counter the “disinformation” promoted by the government and their supporters in the big business lobby.

He says Fight HST’s study, titled: “HST or PST? The truth about the HST and why returning to the PST is better for BC” is a damning indictment of the harmful effects of the HST on the economy and jobs, and is based on information that is publicly available – but has been completely ignored by the BC government throughout the entire HST debate.

“With the HST, also called a Value Added Tax (VAT), there is a long history going all the way back to 1954 in France and up to the present day in Europe, Canada and around the world. It is easy to trace its damaging effects everywhere it has been implemented. Economies in Europe are teetering on the brink of collapse from excessive taxation and the VAT, which is driving large parts of their economies underground to avoid this tax,” said Vander Zalm.

“In Canada the provinces with HST have the highest unemployment, while those without an HST have the lowest – more than half as much in some cases. In BC, unemployment has risen almost a full percentage point since the introduction of the HST, resulting in tens of thousands of job losses. It’s a disaster.”

Vander Zalm says the report shows how the HST in Europe and the Maritimes is responsible for inflation, economic stagnation and an increase in the overall tax burden, including income taxes.

“It is a bad tax system. And any of the touted benefits can easily be achieved without harmonizing our sales taxes with Ottawa. Our report is well researched, and unlike the spurious claims by the pro HST side, it includes references to all sources to support the information contained in it.”

Some of the report’s findings include:

  • VAT’s in Europe began at about 6% and now average 20%, with some countries as high as 25%.
  • Unemployment in Canadian provinces with the HST range between 8.2% in Ontario and BC to 12.4% in Newfoundland.
  • Unemployment in non HST provinces like Alberta, Manitoba and Saskatchewan are in the 5% range – over half the rate of some HST provinces.
  • The HST will cost BC taxpayers an average of $400-$500 each year for every man, woman and child for a total increased tax burden of $10 billion in just the first 5 years of implementation.
  • The HST (VAT) is responsible for shrinking the tax base, increasing government debt, and increasing unemployment.
  • The HST is not necessary to exempt businesses from sales taxes or to streamline compliance.
  • The HST is “revenue neutral” to government with all extra revenues going to tax refunds for business and none to social programs like health care or education.
  • Returning to the PST or a revised form of PST will save BC taxpayers billions of dollars.
  • The HST hands control of BC sales taxes to Ottawa.

Vander Zalm says his group will publish its report on its web site, and will begin a viral marketing campaign using email, Twitter, Facebook and other new media to distribute the report throughout the province so British Columbians can read for themselves how bad the tax is.

He says he and Fight HST spokespersons Chris Delaney and Bill Tieleman will make themselves available to explain the report and to field questions from the media in the coming weeks.

Please forward this report to everyone you know so all British Columbians can know the truth about the HST

REPORT: The Truth About the HST

Share on Facebook

RSS feed


Comment by PABLO AIRO
2011-04-05 12:29:51

Tell me about!!!!!
The worst impact of the HST is the lost of the taxation policy for BC.
I am formerly from Spain and the VAT goes up any time the government feels like.
At the end of last years had another increase to please foreign investment in the finances of the country.

Comment by W Martin
2011-04-05 13:26:14

The Liberals need money, so admit the 30% tax break that bought votes was wrong and reinstate it. The gov`t lost 8 BILLION $ 0n that boo boo.It may cost the Wealthy more and why not?

Comment by NEV BRADLEY
2011-04-05 14:20:54

Please publish a list of names of the “Independent Panel” so we can see how “independent” the government HST panel really is.!

Comment by Blair henderson
2011-04-05 15:59:58

this is just another way for the liberals to get away with their lies So much for Christy Clarke doing what the bc people want.Again total disrespect for the rights and wishes of all us tax payers. What a joke on us.
Remember this when you go to the poles.

Comment by bruno
2011-04-11 20:24:58

Basically, the liberal party, is a sheep,in wolves clothing. Scambull was a conservative. The whole conservative republican agenda started back when Reagan became President of the U.S. His trickle down became a trickle up, and now as a result, the top 5% control an unbelievable portion of the income in North America. When the facts actually become a reality, do you think, that your armed forces will fire on you when you finally have had enough, take your time. It’s ok

Comment by G.J.W.
2011-05-14 12:09:55

The HST was designed for big business and big business only. BC as a province of natural resources, the HST doesn’t benefit the BC people what-so-ever. The HST was just another tax grabbing scam. Count up all of the BC Liberals lies, that speaks for it’s self.

I also don’t trust Elections BC. They were caught in corruption. Craig James altered the wording of the recall, after the fact.

When the Liberals fear they can’t win, they cheat.

Falcon has already said, he doesn’t have to honor the referendum, if he chooses not too. The referendum terms were named under Campbell, not Falcon’s own terms.

Comment by al gribbin
2011-08-03 08:35:34

HST or not, my issue is with this democratic circus of a mail in referendum.
My wife received her ballot in the mail and I expected mine. It never came so I called elections BC.
They explained that it had been sent to a previous address.
BUT when they said that it was up to me to find the ballot through the post office or from the previous address I realized that I have been effectively disenfranchised. Worse yet, what is stopping whoever received the ballot from voting it and sending it in?
I believe that there will be so many problems with this referendum, it will be deemed invalid, HST or not.

Name (required)
E-mail (required - never shown publicly)
Your Comment (smaller size | larger size)
You may use <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong> in your comment.





  • Email the Prime Minister of Canada
  • Email the Governor General of Canada
  • MP Letter Template
  • Prime Minister Letter Template
  • PROVINCIAL MLA LIST (by riding)
    Abbotsford South John van Dongen
    Abbotsford West Mike De Jong
    Abbotsford-Mission Randy Hawes
    Alberni-Pacific Rim Scott Fraser
    Boundary-Similkameen John Slater
    Burnaby North Richard Lee
    Burnaby-Deer Lake Kathy Corrigan
    Burnaby-Edmonds Raj Chouhan
    Burnaby-Lougheed Harry Bloy
    Cariboo North Bob Simpson
    Cariboo-Chilcotin Donna Barnett
    Chilliwack John Les
    Chilliwack-Hope Barry Penner
    Columbia River-Revelstoke Norm MacDonald
    Comox Valley Don McRae
    Coquitlam-Burke Mountain Douglas Horne
    Coquitlam-Maillardville Diane Thorne
    Cowichan Valley Bill Routley
    Delta North Guy Gentner
    Delta South Vicki Huntington
    Esquimalt-Royal Roads Maurine Karagianis
    Fort Langley-Aldergrove Rich Coleman
    Fraser-Nicola Harry Lali
    Juan de Fuca John Horgan
    Kamloops-North Thompson Terry Lake
    Kamloops-South Thompson Kevin Kreuger
    Kelowna-Lake Country Norm Letnick
    Kelowna-Mission Steve Thomson
    Kootenay EastBill Bennett
    Kootenay West Katrine Conroy
    Langley Mary Polak
    Maple Ridge-Mission Marc Dalton
    Maple Ridge-Pitt Meadows Michael Sather
    Nanaimo Leonard Krog
    Nanaimo-North Cowichan Doug Routley
    Nechako Lakes John Rustad
    Nelson-Creston Michelle Mungall
    New Westminster Dawn Black
    North Coast Gary Coons
    North Island Claire Trevena
    North Vancouver-Lonsdale Naomi Yamamoto
    North Vancouver-Seymour Jane Ann Thornwaite
    Oak Bay-Gordon Head Ida Chong
    Parksville-Qualicum Ron Cantelon
    Peace River North Pat Pimm
    Peace River South Blair Lekstrom
    Penticton Bill Barisoff
    Port Coquitlam Mike Farnworth
    Port Moody-Coquitlam Ian Black
    Powell River-Sunshine Coast Nicholas Simons
    Prince George-Mackenzie Pat Bell
    Prince George-Valemount Shirley Bond
    Richmond Centre Rob Howard
    Richmond East Linda Reid
    Richmond-Steveston John Yap
    Saanich North and the Islands Murray Coell
    Saanich South Lana Popham
    Shuswap George Abbott
    Skeena Robin Austin
    Stikine Doug Donaldson
    Surrey-Cloverdale Kevin Falcon
    Surrey-FleetwoodJagrup Brar
    Surrey-Green Timbers Sue Hammell
    Surrey-Newton Harry Bains
    Surrey-Panorama Stephanie Cadieux
    Surrey-Tynehead Dave Hayer
    Surrey-WhalleyBruce Ralston
    Surrey-White Rock Gordon Hogg
    Vancouver-Fairview Margaret MacDiarmid
    Vancouver-False Creek Mary McNeil
    Vancouver-Fraserview Kash Heed
    Vancouver-Hastings Shane Simpson
    Vancouver-Kensington Mabel Elmore
    Vancouver-Kingsway Adrian Dix
    Vancouver-Langara Moira Stilwell
    Vancouver-Mount PleasantJenny Kwan
    Vancouver-Point Grey Gordon Campbell
    Vancouver-Quilchena Colin Hansen
    Vancouver-West End Spencer Herbert
    Vernon-Monashee Eric Foster
    Victoria-Beacon Hill Carole James
    Victoria-Swan Lake Rob Fleming
    West Vancouver-Capilano Ralph Sultan
    West Vancouver-Sea to Sky Joan McIntyre
    Westside-Kelowna Ben Stewart

  • Will you vote NO or YES in the Transit and Transportation Plebiscite?

    View Results

    Loading ... Loading ...
  • Where should the BC Liberals seek money to fix Translink?

    View Results

    Loading ... Loading ...